Skip to main content
The Sorrowing Soul Between Doubt and Faith - Image 1
The Sorrowing Soul Between Doubt and Faith - Image 2
The Sorrowing Soul Between Doubt and Faith - Image 3
The Sorrowing Soul Between Doubt and Faith - Image 4

Elihu Vedder

The Sorrowing Soul Between Doubt and Faith

1898

Thumbnail 1
Thumbnail 2
Thumbnail 3
Thumbnail 4
Scroll

Elihu Vedder

The Sorrowing Soul Between Doubt and Faith

1898

Physical Qualities Oil on canvas, 16 x 22 1/2 in. (40.6 x 57.2 cm) Framed: 24 7/8 x 31 1/4 x 2 3/8 in. (63.2 x 79.4 x 6 cm)
Credit Line Gift of Mme. A. W. L. Tjarda van Starkenborgh-Stachouwer
Object Number 1955.80
Omar Khayàm, a man of great learning in 11th-century Persia, wrote poems that found avid readers in the 19th-century English speaking world. Elihu Vedder created illustrations of 56 of the poet’s verses for a deluxe edition of the Rubàiyàt of Omar Khayàm, published in Boston in 1884. This painting was inspired by the content and style of Vedder’s drawings. Here, three allegorical figures, identified in the border, capture the anguish of a human soul (l’anima) as it struggles between doubt (il dubbio) and faith (la fede). A journalist for The Atlantic Monthly noted the picture’s “universal application, impregnated with that sad poetry which is the distinguishing mark of Vedder’s temperament.” This is the second of two versions. The picture was recently rehoused using a period frame in the Near Eastern taste.
Fischer Galleries, Washington, DC; Theodore Marburg, Baltimore, 1901; to his daughter Mme. van Starkenborgh-Stachouwer; BMA by gift, 1955
AMW Reinstallation 2014

American Wing Rotations 2020

American Wing Rotations 2021

American Wing Rotations 2022

American Wing Rotations 2023

American Wing Rotations 2024

American Wing Rotations 2025
Elihu Vedder, "The Digressions of V." Boston and New York, Houghton Mifflin Co., 1910, p. 497

George Boas, "What is a Picture?" Johns Hopkins Magazine, Vol. VIII December 1956

Baltimore Sun Magazine, Sunday, February 5, 1967, p. 5 illus.

Regina Soria, "Elihu Vedder: American visionary in Rome (1836-1923)" Cranbury, New Jersey, Fairleigh Dickinson University Press, no. 530

Inscribed: Rector, lower right, painted: "Roma Copyright 1899 by E. Vedder" On wood panel on back of painting is pasted a page from a catalog entry from W.H. Downes article that appeared in Atlantic Monthly: "The Vedder Exhibition" 3 The Eclipse of the Sun by the Moon 4 The Sould Between Doubt and Faith $1500 (price handwritten) An allegory of universal application, impregnated with that sad poetry which is the distinguishing mark of Vedder's temperament, is "The Sould between Doubt and Faith," something like a pictorial version of Tennyson's Two Voices - a picture of a divided will, of a mental struggle, of a human soul in anguish. A woman's face darkened by the shadow of a great sorrow, and piteously worn by a moral conflict, appears between two symbollic heads - the serene and radiant head of Faith on the one hand, surrounded by a golden nimbus, and on the other side the shrewd, wrinkled visage of gray-bearded Doubt, who seems to be as righteous as ever in spite of his great age. In either ear these opposing spirits pour their inconclusive arguments. The simplicity of this thought is perfect, and the delineation of a painful psychological mood is a triumph of expression. Into these haggard features Vedder has poured a world of mournful meaning which touches the heart, and moves it to pity for poor humanity thus typified. W.H. Downes in "Atlantic Monthly" June 1887 (date handwritten) Customs seal: Re?gana di Roma / March 30, 1899

Markings: Painted in border along lower edge of canvas (visible when frame removed) the words: "IL DUBBIO L'ANIMA LA FEDE"

Artist

Elihu Vedder

1835–1922

American, 1836-1923
Meet Elihu →
Alexander "Skunder" Boghossian
Blind Faith
1991
Laura Ortman, Nanobah Becker, and others
My Soul Remainer
2016
Amy Sherald
Planes, Rockets, and the Spaces in Between
2017
Marc Chagall, Louis Fort, and others
Plate III from the series "Dead Souls"
1947
Marc Chagall, Louis Fort, and others
Plate LV from the series "Dead Souls"
1947
Alexandre Marie Colin, Théodore Géricault, and others
Combat Between a Lion and a Horse
1823
Adolphe Hervier
Croquis: Femme tenant une paire de souliers, femme les poings sur les hanches, etc.
1849
Hezekiah Wright Smith and Hammatt Billings
Combat Between Ivanhoe and the Templar
1856
Niccolo Schiavonetti and William Blake
The Soul Uniting with the Body
1790–1812
Todd Charles Clayton Webb
Maquette for "Sixth Avenue between 43rd and 44th Streets, New York"
1947
Utagawa Hiroshige and Yamadaya Shōjirō
Wrestling Matches between Mountains and Seas (Sankai mitate zumô)
1857
Utagawa Hiroshige and Yamadaya Shōjirō
Wrestling Matches between Mountains and Seas (Sankai mitate zumô)
1857