[Asma Naeem] This is "For Love, and for Country," painted by Amy Sherald in 2022. At first glance, the scene might seem familiar. A sailor in uniform leans forward and dips his partner into a kiss, a pose that echoes one of the most famous photographs in American history, "V-J Day in Times Square." That 1945 image taken by Alfred Eisenstaedt was published in Life Magazine to celebrate the end of World War II, becoming a symbol of American patriotism and joy. Sherald re-imagines that moment for our time. Her couple is two Black men, their skin rendered in grayscale. Their clothing casual and contemporary. Behind them stretches a field of bright blue as if the whole world has opened up around them. By recasting this familiar image, Sherald invites us to think about who has been pictured in stories of American heroism and who has been left out.
The soldiers returning from war in 1945 came home to parades and headlines, while Black veterans faced segregation and discrimination. Gay service members were forced to conceal their identities for decades under policies like Don't Ask, Don't Tell. Here, Sherald restores their presence in the nation's collective memory and expands the idea of who gets to represent courage and devotion. Sherald turns an intimate gesture into a monument, an image large enough to fill a wall, asserting that these lovers long erased from the nation's visual history deserve a place within it. The scale rivals that of Michelangelo's David. The tenderness of the kiss draws us close, even as the scale reminds us of our own role as witnesses.
There's a tension between the quiet intimacy of the moment and the grandeur of its presentation. The title, "For Love, and for Country," brings the painting's two themes into balance. It's a portrait of affection and pride, but also of insistence, the insistence that love itself can be a form of service, a way of claiming space in a nation that has not always made room for everyone's story. It is therefore, both a love story and a monument, a vision of intimacy elevated to the scale of history itself.
San Francisco Museum of Modern Art, purchase, by exchange, through a gift of Helen and Charles Schwab BMA
A painting depicts two figures with gray-toned skin embracing and kissing against a solid blue background. One figure, wearing a white sailor’s hat and shirt, stands upright while dipping the other, who wears a striped shirt, yellow pants, and holds a white sailor’s hat.